Min, 18 OktFTRed Bull New York0Toronto FC2Kam, 15 OktFTD.C. United2Red Bull New York1Min, 11 OktFTRed Bull New York4San Diego FC1Kam, 1 OktFTRed Bull New York0St. Louis CITY SC3Sab, 19 SepFTNew York City FC0Red Bull New York1Min, 13 SepFTColumbus Crew0Red Bull New York1Kam, 10 SepFTLAFC2Red Bull New York0Min, 6 SepFTSeattle Sounders FC0Red Bull New York0Min, 30 AguFTRed Bull New York1Philadelphia Union3Min, 23 AguFTRed Bull New York1Chicago Fire FC1Kam, 20 AguFTRed Bull New York0Nashville SC1Min, 16 AguFTAtlanta United FC2Red Bull New York1Min, 2 AguFTRed Bull New York3Orlando City SC2Min, 26 JulFTRed Bull New York0Charlotte FC2Kam, 23 JulFTPhiladelphia Union3Red Bull New York1Min, 24 MeiFTSporting Kansas City1Red Bull New York2Min, 17 MeiFTRed Bull New York1New York City FC1Kam, 14 MeiFTRed Bull New York3Columbus Crew2Min, 10 MeiFTChicago Fire FC1Red Bull New York3Min, 3 MeiFTRed Bull New York0FC Dallas2Min, 26 AprFTFC Cincinnati2Red Bull New York0Kam, 23 AprFTRed Bull New York4D.C. United4Min, 19 AprFTCF Montréal4Red Bull New York1Min, 12 AprFTInter Miami CF2Red Bull New York2Min, 5 AprFTRed Bull New York4FC Cincinnati2Min, 22 MarFTCharlotte FC6Red Bull New York1Min, 15 MarFTToronto FC1Red Bull New York1Sen, 9 MarFTRed Bull New York0CF Montréal3Min, 1 MarFTRed Bull New York1New England Revolution0Min, 22 FebFTOrlando City SC1Red Bull New York2
Kiper
| 1 |  Anthony Marcucci | USA · 27 |
| 34 | Ethan Horvath | USA · 31 |
| 77 |  John McCarthy | USA · 34 |
Bek
| 2 | Justin Che | USA · 22 |
| 3 |  Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty | Canada · 22 |
| 5 | Omar Valencia | Panama · 22 |
| 6 |  Robert Voloder | Germany · 25 |
| 12 |  Dylan Nealis | USA · 28 |
| 14 | Julián Bazán | Colombia · 20 |
| 20 | Juan González | Colombia · 22 |
| 26 |  Tim Parker | USA · 33 |
| 45 | Connor Faello | |
| 56 | Matthew Dos Santos | USA · 18 |
| 59 |  Devin Padelford | USA · 23 |
Gelandang
| 8 | David Ruiz | Honduras · 22 |
| 10 | Emil Forsberg | Sweden · 34 |
| 15 | Adri Mehmeti | USA · 17 |
| 39 | Nehuen Benedetti | Argentina · 21 |
| 48 | Ronald Donkor | Ghana · 21 |
| 60 | Sékou Koné | Mali · 20 |
| 66 | Tanner Rosborough | USA · 18 |
| 80 | Nathan Worth | USA · 19 |
| 88 | Pedro Castro |
Penyerang
| 7 |  Cade Cowell | USA · 23 |
| 11 | Jorge Ruvalcaba | Mexico · 25 |
| 13 | Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting | Cameroon · 37 |
| 16 | Julian Hall | USA · 18 |
| 17 |  Cameron Harper | USA · 24 |
| 37 | Mohammed Sofo | Ghana · 21 |
| 70 | Andy Rojas | Costa Rica · 20 |
| 79 | Rafael Mosquera | Panama · 21 |
| 91 | Mijahir Ameth Jiménez Murillo | |
| 92 | Dennis Nelich |